Sittercity? We Tried It And This Is What I Have To Say ...

A Parent's Concern

Every parent — regardless of whether you have a spouse or are a single parent — sooner or later, will be in need of a babysitter. Whether it's because you need to be at work, have an important appointment that you can't miss, or simply need to have a break from family life to keep your sanity ... having a babysitter that you can trust your precious little ones can sometimes (or is it most of the time?) be a challenge.

For the lucky ones who have family members, relatives, or their neighbors to depend on for baby sitting, I envy you. For parents like us who need outside help for baby sitting or do not want to hassle others, we have two options: find baby sitters the old fashioned way through recommendations from family and friends or find baby sitters the modern way via the internet.

Most recently, my husband and I were faced with a situation wherein the only option we had left was to go online to look for a babysitter. We initially had three options and visited the sites of Sittercity, Care.com, and Nannies4Hire.

As parents, one of the most important criteria we have in mind is the safety of our child.

After visiting these websites and checking out what they all had to offer, we decided to further look into Sittercity mostly because the site appeared to be more user-friendly, had more features that we thought were handy and useful, and most of all, was highly recommended by a friend of ours. Upon further comparison with the other two sitter sites, we also found that Sittercity had more available sitters to choose from not only within our city but in most areas in the US.

As parents, one of the most important criteria we have in mind is the safety of our child. Can we trust the babysitter with our little girl? Do we feel comfortable leaving our child with the babysitter alone in our house? Can the baby sitter take care of our child and at the same time be a mentor and sort of a role model? Since we are using an online service, are the baby sitters screened at all? Are they certified to be baby sitters? What about first aid ... are they knowledgeable just in case an incident occurs and they need to be able to administer fist aid.

Watch the video to learn more about Sittercity

I Felt Compelled to Do My Due Diligence

While Sittercity came highly recommended, as a parent, I felt that it was my responsibility to do my due diligence on this service. My husband and I initially combed the web to find out what others had to say about Sittercity. Based on what I have seen, most of those who actually used this service provided positive feedback about Sittercity. Those that had negative feedback on Sittercity pretty much focused on the fee that they had to pay.

Sittercity's homepage

Given that we have seen quite enough actual Sittercity user feedback, we decided to do some background check on Sittercity. Through our research, we found out that Sittercity was started by Genevieve Thiers back in 2001 while she was a Boston College student. She modeled Sittercity after successful online dating services wherein you can try to match those who need babysitters with those willing to provide the service.

From its small initial base of clients in the Boston area, Sittercity has grown and now serves more than half a million users nationwide in cities all across the United States. Sittercity has also expanded the scope of its services to pet sitters, elder care, tutors and more. For us, our interest is just for babysitting for our seven year old. 

Related Read: Sittercity Promo Code Saves You Money

So ... What Can Sittercity Do for Us?

My husband and I were impressed by how Genevieve Thiers was able to grow a simple idea into a service accessible by people on nationwide. After learning about the company's background, we thought that it was time to learn more details about their service. So the main question in our minds was: "What can Sittercity do for us?".

You can refine your search to find your ideal sitter with over 40 major search criteria that includes educational levels, certifications for first aid and CPR, spoken languages, special needs experience, and more.

Aside from being able to look for babysitters from the comfort of my home or office, I have access to a number of sitters searchable by zip code. We thought that this was so simple and really made it easy for us to start our search. You also have the option to post a job and let the babysitters contact you.

So after we punched in the zip code, we were taken to a page where we were able to further narrow our search by distance, whether the babysitter has transportation, whether the babysitter is willing to do light housekeeping, has experience with special-needs kids, etc. Sittercity also allowed us to further narrow down our search to see who has first aid and CPR certification. For us, we think this is very important, just in case something untoward happens (of course, we hope that such a situation does not happen but it is good to know that whoever is watching over our child is capable of really taking care of her).

We were also able to browse through a babysitter's profile, see her availability, do a background check (Sittercity uses LexisNexis for this at $14.99 per background check person), and read through available references, and most importantly, their reviews. For us, the $14.99 background check was well worth it considering that we are insuring the safety of our precious child. As far as we are concerned, this is also an investment for our peace of mind so that we can at least relax knowing that our daughter is safe. Sittercity's background check includes an identity check, a national criminal search, traffic violations, and a check through the sex offender and violent crime registry.

Here is also something to keep in mind regarding the background checks — sometimes you might not even have to pay for a background check. If you find a sitter who does not have a background check in her/his sitter profile, then you have the option to have a background check done, and of course, have to pay for it. However, if a current background check exists in a sitter's profile, then obviously there is no need to have a background check done. That background check might have been done by other parents or subscribers, or by the sitter themselves.

According to Sittercity, usually a babysitter would pay for their own background check so that they can have a profile complete with a background check. By having a background check on their profile, sitters usually have a better chance of getting a job since it makes it more convenient (and cheaper) for the hiring party. Remember, the background check is conducted by a third party, LexisNexis, so the sitter cannot in any way influence or tamper with the findings.

Sittercity also has some great resources on how to hire a babysitter, a rate calculator to determine how much we should pay the babysitter based on the going rate in the area and her background, and an indicator which tells us the last time a babysitter candidate signed into the site. If it has been a long time since the babysitter signed into the site, then she probably might no longer be interested in babysitting.

Important Limitations: Promo Code ONLY Applies With This Link     Important Limitations: Promo Code ONLY Applies With This Link

What Sittercity Isn't

Keep in mind that just like other babysitter services, you may find certain issues with the service if you think that this service will do everything for you. Services like Sittercity only facilitate the process of the search. It provides you with the tools to help narrow down your choices from an extensive pool of baby sitting providers. This means that if you do not know how to narrow down your choice of candidates to a few choices, then you might have tough time finding the right set of candidates to interview. Eventually, the screening criteria starts with you.

If you know what you are looking for in a babysitter, the service can actually do a good job of paring down your choices. The key is for you to know exactly what your requirements or credentials are for your ideal babysitter. Do you want to them to still be in college or a mother who does babysitting on the side? Do you want someone who has their own means transportation?  Do you require someone who knows how to communicate in other languages. How about CPR or first aid? Do you require these? Again, it is important that you know the requirements that will make you feel that you are getting the right babysitter for your child.

Remember, Sittercity is like the eBay or Amazon.com for babysitters and those who need babysitting services — it facilitates the process of finding the right match for those who need the service with those who can provide the service.

Another potential issue that we see with using Sittercity is that some people might let down their guard regarding background checks. Just because a babysitter is listed in Sittercity does not mean that you should assume that Sittercity has done their due diligence in screening people.

Remember, Sittercity is like the eBay or Amazon.com for babysitters and those who need babysitting services — it facilitates the process of finding the right match for those who need the service with those who can provide the service. Once you have chosen the your final list of candidates, it is your responsibility to do the final screening through in-person interviews, going through the reviews of the babysitters, checking with references, and most importantly, background checks.

Sittercity can facilitate the background checking. Even with the $14.99 fee for background checks, we found this worth the investment since I do not think my husband and I can do the comprehensive background check ourselves. Doing so will also cost us more dollar-wise plus time-wise so we really think that this is a great feature.

Looking for a babysitter in your area? Let us help. Simply enter your zip code and click on the "Find" button. Zip Code

Sample Sitter Profile

Below is a typical example of what you will find on a Sittercity sitter's profile page. I know that this is tough to read because the fonts are pretty small and not too clear. However, if you want to see a bigger page and have a better idea of how it looks like, simply click on the image or Click Here.

Sample sitter profile. Click Here to see bigger page

Did We Find Our Ideal Babysitter?

Just like the process in looking for your "ideal" employee, Sittercity helped screen through potential candidates so that we can get to the next stage in the process — the interview.

Interviewing a Babysitter? Avoid the common pitfalls of babysitter interviewing. Learn to ask potential sitters the right questions with this important, yet FREE Babysitter Interview Checklist.

For my husband and I, we arranged for separate face-to-face interviews with potential candidates on Sittercity who matched our criteria. For our final picks, we also arranged for them to just hang-out with our daughter while we're at home just to see how they interact with her. To make a long story short, we eventually settled on someone we can truly trust to look after our daughter whenever we needed a babysitter.

Our Bottom Line Thoughts

A common negative feedback that we have seen about Sittercity is the cost. Sittercity has three payment options: an annual plan that comes down to $7.50 a month billed upfront ($90); a 3-month membership plan that cost $23.33 a month billed upfront ($70); and a monthly plan costing $35 a month. Obviously, the annual plan is a better deal since it cost less (79% savings compared to the monthly plan annualized), which means that you get more bang for your buck.

Do we find the $140 up front fee and additional $14.99 charge for background checks sort of overboard? Personally, not at all. For the convenience and time savings that this service has provided me and my husband in our search for a baby sitter, I believe that this service provides such a great value for our money. We would not have been able to find a great pool of candidates to chose from if it wasn't for Sittercity's extensive list of babysitters within our area. And if it wasn't for the ease of use of  Sittercity's screening process, what would take us hours and hours to do on our own can be done within minutes.

We think of it this way. How much of our time, as well as other people's time, will we be spending just to find a baby sitter the old fashioned way? Well, maybe it's just us but the whole process of finding a babysitter by calling friends and neighbors is, based on our experience, is just a lot of work. Sittercity scores high with us in terms of the convenience and value for your money factors. We definitely would be willing to pay that $7.99 a month for the convenience Sittercity provides us.

Also, if you are not willing to invest $14.99 for a comprehensive background check on people you will be entrusting to look after your kids, we think that for a minimal investment, you are taking too much of a risk, especially when it come to the safety of your precious kids.

Based on our overall experience with Sittercity, is this online babysitter service something that we would recommend to other parents? By making the search process for a babysitter more convenient to do, Sittercity is a service that parents should seriously look into. In short — yes, we would highly recommend this to other parents.

Just in case you are not aware of the other services that Sittercity has, the site also offers searches for petsitters, nannies, housesitters, tutors, and senior care. These are all part your membership, which makes the deal even sweeter. For us, it's nice to know that we have access to all these services within the convenience of our home.

Final Piece of Advice

As a final piece of advice, if you decide to use Sittercity and end up finding a potential babysitter who you think might be perfect to take care of your kids, we suggest that you really spend time learning more about this person. Regardless of how and where you are looking for a babysitter, whether through friends or online, you are always bound to run into some risks. Sittercity has the tools to help you minimize the risks.

As parents, our kids' safety should always be top priority. Hence, we strongly advise that parents should not cut corners and should always do their due diligence on potential candidates such as checking references, reviewing online ratings and feedback, conducting in-person interviews, and most importantly running background checks. We urge you to never be complacent about any potential safety concerns that you may have, especially when it comes to hiring someone you will be entrusting your most valuable asset ... your kids.

I hope my review of Sittercity will help you decide if this online babysitter service is best for you and your family. 

Gigi S.

PS. Aside from getting all the great features that Sittercity has to offer, the following benefits also come with your subscription to Sittercity:

» Automatic membership access to Sittercity Pet Care, Senior Care, Tutoring, and Housekeeping services

» A Sittercity Perks program offering you discounts on everything from clothes to restaurants

» Articles on how to hire a sitter, what to ask in the interview, how to monitor a sitter and much more

» Blogs filled to the brim with advice, humor, news and the latest caregiving trends

» A monthly newsletter with exclusive special offers, new products and cool websites

PS2. If you are still not sure whether Sittercity is for you, we suggest that you give it a try. Sittercity allows you to do some searches on their site for free so that you can have a feel for how their site works. Furthermore, the trial search also gives you a chance to scope out some potential sitters within your neighborhood. The trial search does not require any credit card so feel free to take advantage of this special offer. Simply click on the link below:

Free Trial Search on Sittercity

No credit card required. No strings attached.

Disclosure: Compensated Affiliate

Visit Sittercity Now

Visit Sittercity Now

Actual Customer Reviews

Below are actual user feedback that we found on Sittercity.

This page last updated on